Shirley Plaut Schaefer (1920–2017) was a New York-born painter and graphic artist whose vibrant, color-rich compositions brought a distinctly modern sensibility to the depiction of everyday American life. Born, raised, and educated in New York City, she developed an artistic language that combined the decorative elegance of European Modernism with the energy, architecture, and humanity of her native city. Working primarily in oil painting, but also in watercolor, acrylic, and printmaking, Schaefer explored the expressive possibilities of color, line, and simplified form. Her career spanned more than seven decades, from the flourishing New York art world of the mid-20th century to her later years in Southern California.
In 1964, after more than two decades of artistic dedication, Schaefer achieved a significant professional milestone: a solo exhibition at Pietroantonio Galleries on Manhattan's Upper East Side. The gallery presented a second solo exhibition of her work in 1966. For a woman artist navigating the predominantly male New York art world, these exhibitions represented important recognition at a time when women reportedly accounted for fewer than 3% of solo gallery exhibitions. Her richly colored canvases pushed toward abstraction without abandoning their representational origins. Paintings inspired by the New York skyline, Central Park, and the city's boroughs proved especially popular. Her 1964 exhibition was featured in The New Yorker and was followed by another exhibition at the newly renovated National Bank of North America on Fifth Avenue. By this time, Schaefer had already exhibited at the Museum of Modern Art, the Carnegie Institute, the Everhart Museum in Pennsylvania, and the American Contemporary Art (ACA) Gallery.
Schaefer's first major professional success came in 1943, when, at just twenty-three, she became one of the first female art directors in the Promotions Department of The New York Times. She had recently graduated from the New York School of Fine and Applied Art (later Parsons School of Design) and had also pursued studies at the National Academy of Design. With many male staff members serving in World War II, her creative influence extended well beyond the Promotions Department, and her graphic design work received national recognition for three consecutive years, appearing in successive editions of Art Directors Annual. She also designed the first seal for the Borough of Queens. In 1945, she was offered a position at Harper's Bazaar magazine but declined the opportunity to pursue her painting career.
In 1944, Schaefer married a physician and settled in the Kew Gardens neighborhood of Queens. She and her husband raised two sons, Jay and Michael. As was often expected of married women at the time, she stepped away from outside employment but continued to pursue her artistic ambitions with determination. She established a painting studio in the third-floor attic of their modest home, where her son Jay recalls the ever-present aroma of turpentine and helping his mother stretch her canvases by hand. In the basement, she hosted dance classes led by a retired Radio City Rockette, reflecting a lifelong fascination with movement and the human figure that would frequently find expression in her paintings. Having come of age during the Great Depression, World War II, and the Holocaust, Schaefer was deeply aware of the social and cultural upheavals of her generation. Her Jewish heritage and family faith occasionally emerged as subjects in her work. Jay also recalls accompanying his mother to see Picasso's monumental antiwar painting Guernica during its years in New York, an experience that made a lasting impression on her.
New York itself remained one of Schaefer's greatest muses and an enduring source of visual inspiration. She was particularly fascinated by construction workers and the soaring skyscrapers that transformed the Manhattan skyline during her childhood. Growing up in the city, she witnessed the era in which architectural landmarks such as the Chrysler Building and Empire State Building helped establish New York as the skyscraper capital of the world. The rhythms of urban life, from bustling parks to bridges, streets, and construction sites, continually informed her work. Over the years, she submitted numerous cover illustrations to The New Yorker, featuring familiar city landmarks such as the Museum of Modern Art, Central Park, and the bridges connecting Brooklyn and Queens.
From 1947 through 1957, Schaefer studied with the influential American painter and printmaker Will Barnet (1911–2012) at the Art Students League of New York on West 57th Street. The League followed the European atelier tradition, allowing students to work under the guidance of individual artists whose philosophies and approaches to artmaking shaped their instruction. Barnet (who also taught Mark Rothko and Cy Twombly), celebrated for his poetic and contemplative depictions of figures in everyday life, became an important mentor and enthusiastic supporter of Schaefer's work. His emphasis on simplified forms, carefully balanced compositions, and the expressive potential of the human figure is clearly reflected in her paintings. His encouragement provided meaningful validation for her artistic ambitions, while his sensitivity to the quiet beauty of ordinary life resonated with her own joyful depictions of people and their surroundings.
Schaefer was equally inspired by the French Post-Impressionist and Fauvist master Henri Matisse (1869–1954), whose revolutionary approach to color and form profoundly shaped the development of modern painting. Matisse was still creating his celebrated paper cutouts during Schaefer's early years of artistic study, and his influence remained with her throughout her life. A well-worn book on the artist remains in her son Jay's library today. Matisse's use of broad, flat areas of expressive color, simplified human figures and silhouettes, decorative patterning, and shallow pictorial space—all organized through the interplay of line, shape, and color rather than conventional perspective—became defining characteristics of Schaefer's own visual language. These qualities firmly connect her paintings to the traditions of European Modernism, even as her subjects remained distinctly rooted in 20th-century American life.
In 1978, Schaefer and her husband relocated to the San Diego area, where she continued to paint, teach, and exhibit while also working extensively with the Old Globe Theatre.
We are grateful to Jay Schaefer, Shirley's son, for bringing her work and story to Lost Art Salon. Jay has devoted years to preserving, protecting, and elevating his mother's artistic legacy, and we are delighted to continue that work by introducing her remarkable paintings to new generations of collectors.